I should probably start this with a confession. I’m the proud owner of what my girlfriend has sarcastically dubbed “the Museum of Fitness Optimism” – an ever-growing collection of exercise equipment that enters my home with fanfare and eventually blends into the background like oddly shaped furniture.
Last week, she nearly tripped over the resistance bands I’d left curled up like synthetic snakes on the living room floor. “For God’s sake, Ben! Another casualty for your fitness graveyard?” she muttered, kicking them aside.
She wasn’t wrong. The bands had joined the ranks of abandoned exercise gear scattered throughout our two-bedroom flat – victims of my enthusiastic but ultimately short-lived fitness commitments.
I’ve been thinking about this peculiar habit of mine – this cycle of fitness enthusiasm followed by equipment abandonment. By my rough calculation, I’ve spent somewhere north of £1,200 on various contraptions and gadgets over the past five years. That’s a lot of money for what essentially amounts to expensive coat hangers and dust collectors.
The treadmill was my first major investment. I remember the day it arrived – a hulking beast that the delivery men struggled to maneuver up the narrow staircase to our flat. “Where you putting this, mate?” one asked, sweat beading on his forehead.
“Spare bedroom,” I replied confidently. “Converting it to a home gym.”
The delivery guy exchanged knowing glances with his colleague. I later realized this was probably the look of men who regularly deliver exercise equipment to optimistic buyers, silently betting on how long before it would become furniture.
For the first two weeks, I was religious about it. Every morning, 6:30 AM, I’d drag myself out of bed, pull on my running shorts, and pound away for thirty minutes while watching the news. By week three, I was hitting the snooze button. By week four, the treadmill had become an expensive clothes rack, draped with shirts and jeans I was too lazy to put away properly.
Now it sits in the corner of our spare room, occasionally used when I’m feeling particularly guilty but mostly serving as an oversized paperweight for tax documents and old magazines I keep meaning to recycle.
The exercise bike came next – a more “practical” option, I told myself. It was smaller, less noisy (the neighbors below had complained about the treadmill’s thundering), and I could watch Netflix while using it. Perfect solution!
Except the seat was uncomfortable. Really uncomfortable. Like sitting-on-a-brick uncomfortable. I bought a gel seat cover. That helped, but then I discovered that cycling while watching TV isn’t as easy as it looks. Either I was pedaling too hard to concentrate on the show, or I was so engrossed in the show that I realized I’d stopped pedaling altogether.
The bike lasted longer than the treadmill – about six weeks of regular use. Now it’s positioned near the window, where I occasionally drape damp towels over it to dry. My girlfriend has placed a small potted fern on its console, which I think is her passive-aggressive way of officially converting it to furniture.
Oh, and then there were the kettlebells. Heavy, Soviet-looking things that promised to transform my body with swings and lifts and other movements that looked simple on YouTube but somehow became complicated physics equations when I attempted them. I bought a set of three – 8kg, 12kg, and 16kg.
The 8kg gets used sometimes. The 12kg serves as a doorstop for the bathroom when the window’s open and creating a draft. The 16kg? I’m not entirely sure I’ve ever lifted it beyond getting it into the house. It lives under the coffee table now, where I occasionally stub my toe on it and curse past-Ben’s optimism.
What’s strange is that I’m not naturally a spendthrift person. In most areas of my life, I’m fairly careful with money. I research purchases, compare prices, and generally avoid impulse buys. But something happens to my brain when I read fitness articles or watch transformation videos. There’s a temporary rewiring where I genuinely believe that this time will be different – that this particular piece of equipment will be the one that transforms me from somewhat-soft office worker to the cover model of Men’s Health.
I mentioned this to my friend Jake while we were having pints last weekend. He laughed so hard he nearly spat his beer out. “Mate, you’ve got what my dad calls ‘the catalogue dream,’” he said, wiping his mouth. “You’re not buying fitness equipment; you’re buying the fantasy of a different life.”
That hit uncomfortably close to home. Because he’s right – when I order a new piece of equipment, what I’m really ordering is the imagined future version of myself who uses it consistently. I’m not purchasing an ab-roller; I’m purchasing six-pack abs. I’m not buying dumbbells; I’m buying bigger arms. It’s magical thinking disguised as a practical purchase.
The ab-roller, by the way, is currently serving as a toy for my girlfriend’s cat, who enjoys pushing it across the hardwood floors at 3 AM.
The yoga mat has probably fared the best of all my fitness purchases. It’s been used somewhat regularly, though more often for impromptu naps than actual yoga. There’s something comforting about lying on a squishy mat in the middle of the living room, supposedly about to exercise, but instead staring at the ceiling and contemplating life’s great mysteries – like why I keep buying exercise equipment I don’t use.
My most recent acquisition – just three months ago – was a pull-up bar that fits in the doorframe. Installation required no tools and took literally minutes. It promised to be the most efficient way to build upper body strength with minimal time investment. Perfect for someone like me with a demanding job and limited free time!
I used it exactly seven times before the inevitable happened. Now it hangs there in the doorway between the hallway and kitchen, a sort of fitness memorial that we duck under multiple times daily. Occasionally, if I’m feeling particularly sprightly after my morning coffee, I’ll do a single pull-up on my way to get breakfast. One. And then I’ll feel simultaneously proud of myself for using it and pathetic that a single pull-up now constitutes a workout.
My girlfriend has suggested – multiple times – that we could reclaim substantial living space by getting rid of some of this equipment. Logically, I know she’s right. But there’s an emotional hurdle to clearing out the fitness graveyard: getting rid of the equipment feels like admitting defeat. Like I’m not just abandoning the equipment, but abandoning the better, fitter version of myself I wanted to become.
Plus, there’s the secondary guilt of money wasted. Getting rid of a £300 treadmill that I used for a total of maybe six hours feels like setting fire to £50 notes. At least while it’s sitting there, taking up space, there’s the theoretical possibility I might use it again.
But the truth, which I’m finally beginning to accept, is that it’s not about the equipment at all. My friend Jake was right about the catalogue dream, but it goes deeper than that. Each purchase is a way of outsourcing motivation – as if the mere presence of a treadmill will somehow generate the discipline I need to use it regularly.
I’ve started to realize that the people I know who exercise consistently rarely have elaborate home gym setups. They’ve got maybe one or two basic items, or they just use their body weight, or they go for runs outside. The equipment isn’t creating the habit; the habit exists independently of the equipment.
This revelation hit me last Tuesday when I was stepping around my adjustable dumbbells (currently serving as extremely expensive paperweights next to the sofa) to reach the remote control. I’ve been approaching this all backward. I’ve been trying to buy my way into a fitness routine instead of building the routine first and then supporting it with equipment as needed.
So I’ve made a new rule for myself: no new fitness purchases for one year. And if, after three consecutive months of consistent bodyweight exercises, I still feel I need equipment, I have to use what I already own before buying anything new.
I’ve also designated Sunday afternoons as “actually use the stuff you already have” time – thirty minutes of intentionally using one piece of abandoned equipment. Last Sunday, I dusted off the resistance bands. My arms were sore on Monday, a subtle reminder from my body that the equipment works perfectly fine; it’s the user that’s been malfunctioning.
My girlfriend is skeptical about this new plan, and fair enough – she’s witnessed the cycle too many times. “Just sell some of it,” she suggested again this morning, tripping over the foam roller that has somehow migrated to the bathroom doorway.
“I will,” I promised. “If I don’t use it in the next month, it goes.”
She raised an eyebrow so high it nearly disappeared into her hairline.
“I’m serious this time,” I insisted.
“You said that about the ab wheel,” she reminded me, nudging it with her toe where it sat next to the cat’s food bowl.
She has a point. My track record isn’t great. But there’s something different this time – a willingness to confront the uncomfortable truth that no purchase will ever be a substitute for consistent effort. My collection of abandoned fitness equipment isn’t just gathering dust; it’s teaching me something important about how lasting change actually happens.
And if nothing else, it’s given me a very expensive lesson in human psychology and the economics of optimism. Next time I feel the urge to buy equipment, I’ll just walk around my flat and count the items I already own that promised to change my life.
Though I did see this really interesting weighted jump rope online yesterday that’s supposed to be amazing for cardiovascular health and shoulder definition…
No. No, Ben. We’re not doing this again.
At least not until I’ve worn out something I already own.